Right To Opinion: The Dishonest And Indefensible Response To Disagreement

If a proposition associated with truth value . . . is not backed by reason, argument, and evidence, stating “I have the right to my opinion” does not contribute to any progress in a discussion, lead persons to the truth, or really say anything other than “this is what I believe” and perhaps, curiously more . . . If, after some debate and tackling the fundamental falsehoods of creationism, a creationist happens to say “I have a right to my own opinion,” this says nothing about the truth-value of creationism and perhaps admits that the creationist is not concerned with truth. A proposition about reality is either backed by evidence, reason, and argument and it should be believed . . . or it is not . . . When faced with contradictory evidence for one’s belief, the belief should be relinquished instead of claiming that one has “the right to an opinion. We should care about holding justified true beliefs and take wondrous delight in challenging falsehoods when the situation calls for it.
Read more . . . 

Catholic Voter Guide 2012: Bishops Release Election Advice

The document was released days after the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops announced they had created a new watchdog committee to challenge what they considered an “assault” on religious liberty from Obama administration policies . . . [T]he document does emphasize statements by Pope Benedict XVI on the duty of lawmakers to serve as a “public witness to our faith.”
Read more . . . 

Quote: Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr.

Image via Wikipedia

Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., (October 15, 1917 – February 28, 2007)
American Historian, Writer, Social Critic, and Agnostic

As a historian, I confess to a certain amusement when I hear the Judeo-Christian tradition praised as the source of our concern for human rights. In fact, the great religious ages were notable for their indifference to human rights in the contemporary sense. They were notorious not only for acquiescence in poverty, inequality, exploitation and oppression but for enthusiastic justifications of slavery, persecution, abandonment of small children, torture, genocide.

Drive-Thru Baloney: Don’t Buy ‘Christian Nation’ Propagandist David Barton’s Junk Food History

Barton claims that through “exhaustive research” he has become an “expert in historical and constitutional issues” and that he owns a “massive library” filled with “tens of thousands of original writings from the Founding Era.” What he does not say is far more telling he makes no mention of any degrees or training in history, because he doesn’t have any . . . Drive Thru History America is a revisionist, biased text written by a hack historian and it should be kept out of all classrooms.
Read more . . .  

It’s 2011 — Why Is God Still Involved In American Politics?

. . . [I]t’s indicative of a larger eroding of the separation of church and state, which concerns not just atheists but all people who understand the importance of maintaining a secular government . . . We’re a long way from the days when John Kennedy assured the public that he respected the separation of church and state and would keep his faith separate from his policy-making decisions . . . Things that used to be considered beyond the pale in politics, such as religious intolerance or ministers blatantly claiming they know who God supports in an election, have become normalized . . . Neither atheists nor believers benefit when leaders are guided more by religious dogma than by rationality. Angels and demons might be a fine thing to worry about when you’re in church on Sunday, but when you’re trying to govern real people in the real world, it’s far better to rely on evidence and empirical facts, interpreted through reason and not through the guesswork of faith.
Read more . . .

Telling Children Hell Exists is Child Abuse

Mythology, which is a category that for Dawkins includes all the major religions, is explained as a collection of ancient Just So stories. Enjoyable as the story of the Garden of Eden (or the Tasmanian aboriginal god who forgot to give humans knees) may be, The Magic of Reality insists that science composes stories as thrilling as those found in Homer, as profound as the story of Job, and as entertaining as anything written by Kipling. . . The other one I thought of was telling children about hell – telling them they’ll go to hell if they’re bad. I think that’s child abuse because it’s genuinely frightening. Many adults, especially Catholic adults, never really manage to shake off that fear and guilt they imbibed as children . . . ” “It’s almost as though in America they’ve become a different species. There are the reasonable people who are educated and believe in science education and then there are the know-nothings, who mostly vote Republican, and they’re kind of diverging . . . ” “Sensible Christians don’t try to fight science but evangelicals do and Muslims do.”
Read more. . .